By: Martha C. White
December 1, 2011
American Dream deferred: We now embrace more modest, personal goals
As conceptual ideals go, the American Dream is pretty iconic. And for a long time, it was pretty easy to define: People worked to earn a college degree, get a good job, buy a house and have a spouse and kids. But then the Great Recession came along and upended everything. Now, our goals are more modest -- like having a financial safety net -- but are still out of reach for many Americans, especially those approaching retirement age. Nearly half -- 44% -- of Americans say they're working harder than their parents did at their age. In MetLife's fifth annual survey about the American Dream, more than 80% of respondents say attaining the American Dream is very or somewhat important, but the yardstick we've used to measure whether or not we're living that dream has changed drastically. Some of the shift is generational: 41% of all respondents say the American Dream is about personal fulfillment. But within that total, there's a big gap. While only a third of Boomers agree with that statement, more than half of Gen Y respondents do.
Our outlook about wealth and material possessions has changed, too. Roughly three-quarters of us say we have what we need, but last year, only 58% of respondents agreed with that assessment. Nearly two-thirds say it's possible to achieve the American Dream without a college degree; 59% say it can be done without owning a home. An even larger percentage -- 70% -- say it's within reach even if you're not wealthy or don't have kids, a stark contrast from traditional thinking, says Beth Hirshhorn, MetLife chief marketing officer.
"They're shifting from the traditional definition of a nuclear family to broader relationships," she says, while the drive for financial success has been replaced by a desire for financial security.
These more modest desires don't mean that the American Dream is any more attainable, though. Three quarters of Baby Boomers say a financial safety net is crucial to achieving the American Dream, but nearly as many say they don't have a safety net in place. While 57% say they're living paycheck to paycheck, 28% say they still plan to rely on the government and their employers' retirement plans and simply hope that's enough to support them through their senior years. However, less than 20% of Gen Y respondents say the same thing.
"This shift from institutions to individuals is actually putting the dream at risk," says Hirshhorn. Younger Americans are more cynical, or perhaps more realistic. "Gen Ys and Xs never expected these programs to be around for them," she says. "Trust in every institution out there has dramatically declined."
The self-sufficiency Americans increasingly have to display when it comes to their financial and retirement security are likely to be behind the more personal incarnation of the American Dream, Hirshhorn says. Since they have to rely more on themselves, they tend to view their successes through the same lens. "People are defining the Dream much more personally," she says. "To that extent, a sense of personal fulfillment is what drives the Dream."